What is the Island Rule?
What is the Island Rule in Biogeography?
The island rule is a pattern in evolution that suggests that organisms that colonize islands tend to become either much larger or much smaller than their mainland counterparts. This pattern has been observed in a variety of organisms, from Komodo dragons to Galapagos giant tortoises. However, recent studies have called into question the validity of this rule, and the debate over its existence continues.
One of the primary reasons that the island rule has been contested is due to the difficulty in untangling the various ecological pressures that organisms face when colonizing islands. The classical theory suggests that organisms become island giants because there is no predation pressure on the islands, allowing them to evolve a larger size without fear of predation. Conversely, island dwarfism occurs because organisms are limited in food availability on the islands, which causes them to evolve smaller body sizes.
Problems with Island Gigantism
However, recent studies have shown that the existence of the island rule may not be as clear-cut as this theory suggests. A review paper published in 2018 found that the island rule was only found in about half of published studies. Additionally, a meta-analysis of island rule studies in bats found that the existence of the rule was more like a coin flip, with a 50/50 chance of observing the pattern.
One of the primary challenges in determining the existence of the island rule is the effect of extinct taxa on the findings. Extinct taxa can change the pattern that we observe in living organisms, and it is difficult to incorporate them into studies. Additionally, there is a bias in living organisms when it comes to the island rule, as larger organisms were often hunted to extinction for their meat or because they posed a danger to humans.
Despite these challenges, some studies have found evidence for the island rule, particularly in mammals. However, the existence of the rule remains contested, and it is likely that the pattern is more nuanced than originally thought. As with many things in ecology and evolution, there are rarely universal patterns, and the existence of the island rule may be more of a murky pattern than a firm rule.
Overall, the island rule is a fascinating topic in evolutionary biology that continues to be debated. While the existence of the rule is contested, it remains an important area of research for understanding how organisms evolve in response to different ecological pressures.
Note: The text above was summarized from the video transcript using AI. Minor corrections for clarity and accuracy were added by Dillon Jones
Sources: